SmallBizGenius Analysis

Milanicosmetics, while praised for the quality and pigmentation of its eyeshadows, faces significant criticism regarding its customer service and order fulfillment. Customers report issues with delayed or missing orders, unresponsive customer support, and discrepancies in product delivery.

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 18 recent reviews

Customer Service

2.0/10

Numerous reviewers express frustration with Milanicosmetics' customer service, citing slow response times, unhelpful representatives, and a lack of resolution to their issues. Many report difficulty getting responses to inquiries about missing orders or incorrect products, with some specifically naming customer care representatives Carol Akinyi and Sophy Arunda.

12 reviews mention this

Shipping & Delivery

2.5/10

A significant number of reviewers report problems with shipping and delivery, including delayed orders, missing packages, and broken tracking links. Several customers state that their orders never arrived, despite having paid for delivery, and that customer service failed to provide adequate assistance or updates.

10 reviews mention this

Product Quality

8.5/10

Several reviewers praise the quality and pigmentation of Milanicosmetics' makeup products, particularly the eyeshadows and concealers. They highlight the creaminess, richness, and long-lasting wear of the products, with some specifically mentioning the 'Conceal + Perfect' line.

7 reviews mention this

Website Experience

3.0/10

Some reviewers report issues with the Milanicosmetics website, including broken tracking links and difficulty finding shade matches. One reviewer specifically mentions the lack of swatches for concealers, making it difficult to find the right shade online.

3 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

High-quality eyeshadows with rich pigmentation Mentioned 5x
"Eyeshadows are amazingly creamy, rich and pigmented. GORGEOUS PALLETS"
Good color match for some users Mentioned 2x
"It's rare for me to find a close match to my skin shade"
Products are cruelty free Mentioned 0x
"N/A"

Common Complaints

Unresponsive and unhelpful customer service Mentioned 12x
"customer service is terrible and won't help me after several attempts to get my order."
Frequent shipping delays and missing orders Mentioned 10x
"Ordered from the website, but it never showed up. Paid £5 for delivery as well."
Broken tracking links and lack of order updates Mentioned 3x
"What is not okay from this company is to send you a completely useless link as every time I click it, it keeps saying the order is not valid or does not exist."
Difficulty obtaining refunds or replacements Mentioned 3x
"After they responded saying I would get a refund, still haven't received it almost 3 weeks later."
Inconsistent product quality Mentioned 1x
"Awful quality: Every other review seems to just be about delivery but I bought a Milani eyebrow pomade from boots and the quality is absolutely appalling"

Common Questions About Milanicosmetics

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is Milanicosmetics legit and trustworthy?

While Milanicosmetics is a real company selling makeup products, the numerous negative reviews regarding customer service and order fulfillment raise concerns about its trustworthiness. Many customers report issues with delayed or missing orders, unresponsive customer support, and broken tracking links. While some customers have positive experiences with the product quality, the prevalence of negative feedback suggests that ordering from Milanicosmetics carries a significant risk of encountering problems.

Based on 15 reviews

Does Milanicosmetics have good customer service?

Based on the reviews, Milanicosmetics' customer service is a major point of concern. Many customers describe it as unresponsive, unhelpful, and slow to resolve issues. Reviewers report difficulty getting responses to inquiries about missing orders, incorrect products, or refund requests, with some waiting weeks for a reply. The negative feedback suggests that customers should not expect prompt or effective assistance from Milanicosmetics' customer service team.

Based on 12 reviews

Is Milanicosmetics worth it for small business?

For small businesses, Milanicosmetics may not be a reliable choice due to the reported issues with customer service and order fulfillment. The risk of delayed or missing orders, coupled with the potential for unresponsive customer support, could disrupt business operations and damage customer relationships. While the makeup quality may be appealing, the inconsistent service quality makes it a risky option for businesses that require dependable and timely service.

Based on 5 reviews

What is Milanicosmetics' shipping policy like?

Milanicosmetics' shipping policy is not explicitly detailed in the reviews, but customer experiences suggest that it is unreliable. Many reviewers report significant delays in order processing and delivery, with some orders taking weeks to arrive or never arriving at all. Additionally, several customers mention broken tracking links and a lack of updates on their order status, making it difficult to monitor the progress of their shipments. The shipping process appears to be a major source of frustration for Milanicosmetics customers.

Based on 10 reviews

What is Milanicosmetics' return policy like?

The reviews do not provide specific details about Milanicosmetics' formal return policy. However, several customers mention difficulty obtaining refunds or replacements for incorrect or missing products, suggesting that the return process may be challenging. The lack of clear information and the reported issues with customer service make it difficult to assess the ease and effectiveness of returns with Milanicosmetics.

Based on 3 reviews

Ready to Try Milanicosmetics?

Save on your first purchase with 5 verified coupon codes.

View Coupons

Looking for Something Different?

Compare Milanicosmetics against 123 similar beauty & salon options.

View Alternatives